On July 10, 2009, C. Martin Gaskell filed a complaint with the U.S. District Court in Kentucky against the University of Kentucky, alleging that he was turned down for the position of Director of the MacAdam Student Observatory on the basis of his religious beliefs and his expression of those beliefs.

On November 23, 2010, the court denied the defendant's and the plaintiff's requests for summary judgment, which sets the stage for a jury trial.

On January 18, 2011, the parties reached a settlement in which Gaskell received $125,000. The University did not admit any wrongdoing.

Attachment	Size
7/10/09: Original Complaint	93.04 KB
8/28/09: Defendant's Answer to Complaint	15.55 KB
1/13/10: Deposition of C. Martin Gaskell	3.02 MB
3/12/10: Deposition of Tom Troland - 1	4.7 MB
3/12/10: Deposition of Tom Troland - 2	2.45 MB
3/12/10: Deposition of Tom Troland - 3	8.2 MB
3/12/10: Deposition of Tom Troland - 4	4.43 MB
3/23/10: Deposition of Gary Ferland	538.42 KB
3/23/10: Deposition of Michael Kovash	1.52 MB
3/24/10: Deposition of James Krupa	194.15 KB
3/24/10: Deposition of Jeffrey Osborn	265.56 KB
3/24/10: Deposition of Sheldon Steiner	213.5 KB
3/31/10: Deposition of Keith MacAdam	163.3 KB
3/31/10: Deposition of Michael Cavagnero	7.81 MB
4/9/10: Deposition of Patty Bender	1.87 MB
4/9/10: Deposition of Sally Shafer	1.66 MB
4/12/10: Deposition of Moshe Elitzur	113.2 KB
5/5/10: Deposition of Steve Ellis - 1	246.2 KB
5/5/10: Deposition of Steve Ellis - 2	1.7 MB
5/12/10: Deposition 2 of James Krupa	229.07 KB
5/12/10: Deposition of Isaac Shlosman	310.27 KB
5/21/10: Deposition of Steve Hoch	444.4 KB
6/9/10: Deposition of John Pica	370.9 KB
9/28/10: Plaintiff Motion for Summary Judgment	132.04 KB
9/28/10: Memorandum Supporting Summary Judgment for Plaintiff	297.27 KB
9/29/10: Defendant Motion for Summary Judgment	29.34 KB
9/29/10: Memorandum in Support of Defendant Motion	211.66 KB
9/29/10: Order Proposed by Defendant	17.9 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh. 2 - Job Posting	791.83 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 3 - Cavagnero Email 8/20/07	945.65 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 4 - Gaskell Application	331.31 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 5 - Gaskell CV	794.1 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 7 - Cavagnero-Troland Email 9/5/07	555.71 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 8 - Cavagnero Email 8/20/07	295.45 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 9 - Cavagnero-Gaskell Email 8/21/07	389.4 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 10 - Kirby Email 5/25/06	405.36 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 11 - Cavagnero-Troland Email 9/19/07	422.75 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 12 - Gaskell Lecture Notes	848.96 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 14 - Cavagnero Email 9/21/07	348.29 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 15 - Cavanero Email 10/1/07	844.29 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 17 - Hoch-Cavagnero Email 10/1/07	521.29 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 18 - Cavagnero Email 10/4/07	1.6 MB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 22 - Cavagnero Email 10/11/07	370.95 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 23 - Troland Email 10/16/07	574.64 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 25 - Troland Email 9/24/07	637.69 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 26 - Candidate Qualifications Chart	1.36 MB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 27 - Troland Email 10/23/07	708.28 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 29 - Troland Email 10/19/07	520.22 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 30 Cavagnero Email 10/21/07	1.82 MB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 31 - Notice of Right to Sue	455.43 KB
9/29/10: Defense Exh 35 - Cavagnero Email 10/17/07	1.76 MB
10/15/10: Plaintiff's Response to Defendant's Motion	4.93 MB
10/19/10: Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Motion	2.16 MB
10/29/10: Defendant's Reply to Plaintiff's Response	37.58 KB
11/1/10: Plaintiff's Reply to Defendant's Response	1.22 MB
11/23/10: Court Denies All Motions for Judgment	218.33 KB
12/16/10: Defense Pretrial Memorandum and lists of Witnesses & Exhibits	97.29 KB
12/16/10: Plaintiff's Pretrial Memorandum	98.69 KB
12/16/10: Plaintiff's Motion In Limine	156.09 KB
12/16/10: Plaintiff's Witness List	85.34 KB
12/16/10: Plaintiff's Amended Witness List	83.18 KB
12/16/10: Plaintiff's Exhibit List	81.5 KB
12/22/10: Defense's Answers to Interrogatories	1.94 MB
12/22/10: Defense Motion in Limine re Several Parties	30.55 KB
12/22/10: Defense Motion in Limine re Michael Kovash	24.14 KB
12/22/10: Defense Response to Plaintiff's Motion in Limine	25.15 KB
12/22/10: Defense Response to Plaintiff's Requests	1.6 MB
12/22/10: Plaintiff Response to Defense Filings	96.25 KB
12/28/10: Case referred to Judge Robert Wier	136.26 KB
1/5/11: Plaintiff's Proposed Jury Instructions	99.46 KB
1/6/11: ACLJ Letter added to Exhibits	40.8 KB
1/6/11: Defense's Proposed Jury Instructions	68.41 KB
1/6/11: Order on Motion In Limine	47.37 KB
1/12/11: Order to Exclude Job Search Information	139.64 KB
1/18/11: Joint Motion to Dismiss	19.9 KB
1/18/11: Order Referring Case to Mediation	135.34 KB
1/18/11: Release and Settlement Agreement	1.17 MB